Other Mommy - not as good as its sourc material, but not bad, either.
Other Mommy, starring Jessica Chastain, Jay Duplass, and Arabella Oliva Clark, is an adaptation of Josh Malerman’s 2024 novel, Incidents Around the House. If you follow my reviews, you know I loved Incidents Around the House, and thought it was scary, innovative, and easily one of the best horror novels I have read in years. Once I finished it, I thought, “This would make a good movie,” and just a few weeks later, I saw the first trailer for the film.
The story centers on the Martin family – Mom and Dad Ursula and Russell (Jessica Chastain and Jay Duplass) and seven-year-old Bela (Clark), a small family that on the surface appears to be the picture of suburban familial bliss. It doesn’t take long for the viewer to perceive that there is tension in the marriage, especially after Bela reports smelling “someone else” on Mommy. And then there is “Other Mommy,” a spectral, shape-shifting, malleable doppelganger of her mother that has been visiting Bela for some weeks, asking to be “let into her heart.” Other Mommy seems to be getting impatient with Bela's hesitance to "let her into her heart", and soon no longer hides herself from the adults in her life, setting in motion a roller coaster of encounters that ropes in everyone from kids at a playground, Uncle Frank (the man whom Ursula is having an affair with), and Ursula’s mother (Karen Allen).
Other Mommy starts off and largely remains a relatively faithful adaptation to the overall structure of the novel. Told entirely from Bela’s perspective, the book is masterfully suspenseful and scary, especially because it's seen through the eyes of a child. Once Other Mommy is revealed to others, the movie assumes the same frenetic pace of the novel as the family flees from one place to the next to escape her, all to no avail. The biggest departure, as I expected, is with the ending (don’t worry – no spoilers here), and thanks to CGI, the various forms Other Mommy takes.
Other Mommy shifts shapes in the book, all to creepy effect. In the film, her shape-shifting goes nuclear thanks to movie magic, the results of which are sometimes over the top and downright silly. People who take umbrage at these sorts of changes, however, should remember that a film is not a book, and vice versa. Modern film-going audiences have come to expect bigger, badder special effects, and Other Mommy provides it.
The movie does a decent enough job of retaining the tense, almost hopeless tone of the novel, and fans of horror films will likely enjoy some of the fever-dreamish sequences devised by the special effects department.
Not the best adaptation, but a decent one.



Comments