The Blair Witch Project, Revisited
When The Blair Witch Project was released in 1999, it became a cultural phenomenon – a quintessential “water cooler” topic. In an era prior to social media and the glut of massive franchises, it became the “It” movie to see, mostly by very enthusiastic word of mouth. It eventually became one of the most successful independent films of all time, revitalizing, if not even redefining, the “found footage” genre, and launching a franchise – though every subsequent “project” pales in comparison to the original. The question is: does it still hold up today?
The answer is yes.
The story is simple enough: three friends, Heather, Mike, and Josh, venture into the woods of Burkittsville, Maryland, to make a documentary about the legendary “Blair Witch,” a bit of local folklore that some of the townspeople they interview swear to be true, while others insist it is little more than a tall tale. The film starts slowly. We get pictures of the three amateur documentarians, three average college-aged kids, and early sequences of the film appear to be exactly what it is supposed to be: a zero-budget local documentary. Once the filmmakers move into the woods to camp, the film starts to take a dark and sinister turn. Every night, Heather, Mike, and Josh hear strange and frightening noises and wake up to find that something was in their camp, leaving clues behind such as spooky-looking wood arrangements and covering a pack with slime. Eventually, they become lost; Josh vanishes, and the film descends into a terrifying trek through the woods in which Heather and Mike search for Josh, all the while being tormented by someone or something out there.
What makes the success of The Blair Witch Project so impressive is the fact that very little happens in it. Much like in Jaws and Psycho, two other groundbreaking horror classics, where you don’t see the shark the first half of the movie and never actually see Janet Leigh get stabbed, a majority of the terror happens purely in the audience’s mind. While we see the creepy woodcrafts and symbols, see the tampering done with their camp, and hear some of the eerie noises that torment them, it is mostly through the reactions of the actors that we get pulled into the scene. There’s one scene that comes to mind in particular: when Heather and Mike burst from their tent one night, and Heather screams, “WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT?” you never see anything, and at that point, you hardly hear the spirits of the woods anymore, and yet, you as a viewer are right there running with them. The unknown is far more terrifying than anything CGI could conjure.
The jerky camera movements (which give some viewers vertigo), the tight camera angles, the darkness of the woods, and the whiteness of the camera light make the film feel uncomfortably close and intimate, especially in what is arguably the most famous scene in the film, that in which Heather, in extreme close-up, in essence records her goodbye message to her family, as well as issuing an apology to her friends' families for everything that has happened.
Another reason The Blair Witch Project still works so well is its element of plausibility, which is a lesson in horror many writers and filmmakers seem to forget. One of the reasons the aforementioned Jaws and Psycho are still frightening is that sharks and psychos really exist. Anyone who’s ever gone camping or even just on a hike in the deep woods can relate to the horror of being lost and stranded in the middle of nowhere with no food, water, or cell phone, and how any of us, after a while, would start to break down in the middle of the night when surrounded by darkness and unfamiliar, unexplainable noises and phenomena. For most of the film, we as viewers don’t even know if this is really happening at all or if it is all in the characters’ minds (though after this most recent view, I think it’s pretty clear it is happening), the uncertainty of which makes it even more frightening.
The Blair Witch Project, like all things that are ultimately successful, came along at the right time. And yet, it offers a blueprint to other horror writers and filmmakers: sometimes, less is more; plausibility is far scarier than fantasy; all stories that end up enduring do so because of the people, and while the characters of The Blair Witch Project aren’t entirely fleshed out, the actors, the camera work, the tone, and subtle technique, draw you into their story.
The Blair Witch Project is still scary today, indeed. I wish Hollywood made more things like it.



Comments